Writing a Muslim Character
The Mods of the Magnus Writers discord server and community are putting together a variety of resources for Magnus Archives fan creators; these have been collated from articles on the topics, our own experiences, and the experiences of the members of the Magnus Writers discord. These are definitely not comprehensive or the only viewpoints out there, and are by no means meant as a way to police fanworks, but as a way to support and inspire fan creators in creating thoughtful and diverse works. Please note that external links will be added in a reblog to outsmart tumblr’s terrible tagging system, so make sure to check those out as well!
This resource in particular was put together by Mod Jasmine: hi, all!
While there are no canonically Muslim characters in TMA, Muslim headcanons are common in fanworks—particularly for Basira, and sometimes Jon (which I love to see!). I have cobbled together this post from my own experiences to help support and inform fans in these areas, and as part of my diabolical plan to get more Muslim!Basira and Muslim!Jon fics to shove into my brain.
First, two gigantic caveats:
- I was raised Sunni Muslim in Egypt, which is a majority Sunni Muslim country, and still live there. This means my experience will be very different from someone raised in a majority Christian country like the UK, and different again if they are not Sunni and not Arab.
- I am currently ex-Muslim. This does not mean I bear any ill will towards Islam or Muslims, just that it wasn’t for me, and I felt it was important to be upfront about that. I’ll be linking to resources by practicing Muslims in the reblog to this post, whether to add to my opinions and experiences or provide you with a different opinion. I am not here to put my voice over that of Muslims, just to do some of the work so they don’t have to. Obviously, if any Muslims have any additions or suggestions for this post, I’m happy to accommodate them.
Alright. Now that that’s out of the way, let’s get started with the basics of writing a Muslim character.
(Warning: this is absurdly, absurdly long)
Please see the below links for the articles referenced throughout this post, as well as a few additional resources:
Background
Prayer
Everyday Life
LGBTQ Muslims
As a warning, some of these resources contain instances of queerphobia and Islamophobia, so proceed with caution.
- On Non-Binary Muslims
- Like many gay Muslim people, I have no faith in Pride
- How Queer Muslims are Working to End Stigma This Ramadan
- I didn’t know that being asexual was a thing, until someone asked me what I actually wanted
- How I Came Out of the Closet, Converted to islam, and Found my True Self
- How a Pilgrimage to Mecca Helped Me Embrace My Queer Muslim Identity
- Queer Muslim Masterpost
If you want to do some further reading, check out Writing With Color’s Muslim Characters roundup.
You could also take a look through this tumblr.
And finally, as a reward for sticking with me this long, here’s a bonus TMA comic that asks: are statements halal?






